Adding a pool to your backyard is an exciting decision, but choosing between an inground or above-ground pool can be challenging. Both options offer unique benefits, from affordability and quick installation to long-term durability and customization. The right choice depends on your budget, space, lifestyle, and long-term goals. In this guide, we’ll compare these two pool types to help you determine which one best fits your needs.
Cost Considerations
One of the first factors homeowners consider is cost. The price difference between inground and above-ground pools can be significant.
- Inground Pools: Typically range from $45,000 to $100,000+, depending on size, materials (vinyl, fiberglass, or concrete), and additional features like waterfalls or lighting.
- Above-Ground Pools: More budget-friendly, with prices ranging from $2,500 to $10,000 for a high-quality setup.
- Long-Term Costs: Inground pools may have higher maintenance and repair costs over time, while above-ground pools require liner replacements every 5-10 years.
If budget is a major factor, an above-ground pool offers an affordable way to enjoy backyard swimming. If you’re looking for a long-term investment, an inground pool might be worth the higher upfront cost.
Installation & Timeframe
How quickly do you want your pool ready for swimming? Installation time varies greatly between the two options.
- Inground Pools: Installation can take weeks to months, requiring excavation, plumbing, and permits.
- Above-Ground Pools: Can be installed in a few days, often as a DIY project or with professional assistance.
- Permits & Regulations: Inground pools usually require local permits and inspections, while above-ground pools may have fewer regulatory requirements.
If you’re looking for a quick and easy pool solution, an above-ground pool is the way to go. If you’re willing to wait for a fully customized, long-term installation, inground pools offer more options.
Aesthetics & Customization
For many homeowners, the look and feel of their pool is just as important as functionality.
- Inground Pools: Fully customizable in shape, depth, and design, allowing for add-ons like waterfallsand tanning ledges.
- Above-Ground Pools: Available in pre-made sizes and shapes, but can be enhanced with decking, landscaping, and lighting.
- Integration with Backyard: Inground pools blend seamlessly into landscaping, while above-ground pools may stand out more but can still be stylishly incorporated.
If customization is a priority, an inground pool offers endless possibilities. If you prefer a functional and affordable solution, an above-ground pool with added decking can still create an inviting backyard retreat.
Family & Lifestyle Needs
Consider who will be using the pool and how it fits your lifestyle.
- Inground Pools: Offer deeper swimming areas, diving options, and built-in seating, making them ideal for families, fitness, and entertaining.
- Above-Ground Pools: Provide a safe, shallow swimming environment perfect for kids, with add-ons like decks.
- Safety Considerations: Both pool types require proper fencing and covers to ensure safety.
For a permanent family gathering space, an inground pool is the best choice. If you want an affordable and fun summer activity, an above-ground pool is a great alternative.
Resale Value & Investment
If you’re thinking about future resale value, here’s what to consider:
- Inground Pools: Can increase home value but may not always provide a full return on investment.
- Above-Ground Pools: Generally do not add resale value but can be removed if needed.
- Buyer Preferences: Some buyers view inground pools as a luxury addition, while others may see maintenance costs as a drawback.
If you’re thinking long-term investment, an inground pool may add appeal to your home. If flexibility is more important, an above-ground pool can be a temporary feature.
Which Pool is Right for You?
When deciding between an inground or above-ground pool, consider your budget, backyard space, and long-term goals:
✔ Choose an inground pool if you want a permanent, luxurious, and fully customizable swimming space.
✔ Choose an above-ground pool if you want an affordable, quick-install, and easy-to-maintain backyard pool.
Still unsure which pool is right for you? Our experts at Paquette Pools & Spas are here to help! Contact us today for expert guidance and explore our wide range of pool options.
